Q: Can I admit I lied in a police report about my father hitting my brother as a minor?

A: I’m sorry to hear about the difficult situation you’ve experienced. In New York, the decision to come forward and admit that you lied in a police report is significant, and there are several factors to consider when deciding how to proceed.

First, it's important to understand that lying in a police report is considered making a false statement. If you were a minor at the time, the legal system may view the situation differently compared to if you had been an adult. However, the fact that you were forced to lie by your father could be a significant factor when considering the legal implications of admitting that you lied.

The potential criminal repercussions for admitting that you lied in the police report depend on several factors. In New York, making a false statement to law enforcement can be charged under Penal Law § 210.45, which makes it a crime to provide false information to the police with the intent to mislead them during an investigation. However, since the case has already been adjudicated and there were no legal consequences for the court case, it’s possible that the opportunity for prosecution may be limited, especially if the information you provided did not affect the outcome of the case.

In this case, if the court case has already concluded and your statement did not impact the legal proceedings or lead to an injustice, the chances of facing criminal charges for your earlier lie are likely minimal. However, you should still be cautious, as there could be legal risks depending on the circumstances surrounding the case and any ongoing legal matters.

If you decide to come forward, it is highly advisable to consult with a criminal defense attorney or a family law attorney before doing so. An attorney can help you understand your options and any potential consequences. They can also advise you on how to proceed in a way that minimizes your risk of legal consequences. The lawyer might suggest voluntarily disclosing the truth to the appropriate authorities, potentially through a written statement or a formal retraction of your previous statement. This process can help you take responsibility for your actions while also considering your position as a minor at the time and any coercion you might have experienced from your father.

It’s also worth noting that the emotional and psychological effects of lying about such an incident can be significant, and an attorney may help you navigate any steps that are necessary for your peace of mind, such as seeking therapy or other support services.

Disclaimer: This response is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For personalized guidance, please consult a qualified attorney licensed in New York.

A: Your situation sounds incredibly difficult, and it takes courage to want to come forward with the truth. Being forced to lie as a minor under parental pressure put you in an unfair position, and it's understandable you want to set the record straight now that you're out of that environment.

Coming forward about a false police report could potentially involve legal risks, as filing false reports is generally against the law. However, several factors might work in your favor: you were a minor under your father's influence, considerable time has passed, and the case ended without legal consequences. Before taking any action, you should consult with a lawyer who practices criminal law in your jurisdiction to understand the specific risks and protections that might apply in your case.

If you decide to proceed after legal consultation, you might consider writing a formal statement with your lawyer's guidance, possibly approaching the district attorney's office rather than the police directly. You might also explore whether victim advocacy services could provide support during this process. Remember that coming forward serves justice and your own healing, but timing and approach matter greatly for your wellbeing and legal safety.