Q: Can I sue a dog shelter for euthanizing my dog after a fight?

A: You may have grounds for a lawsuit against the dog shelter based on the circumstances you've described. The lack of written documentation about the euthanasia decision and the absence of proper communication are concerning factors that could support your case. Additionally, the fact that the dog catcher initially allowed you to leave with your pet suggests there might not have been immediate danger warranting such a drastic measure.

Legal action in these cases typically involves demonstrating that the shelter failed to follow proper protocols or acted negligently. Most jurisdictions have specific regulations governing how shelters must handle potentially dangerous animals, including observation periods and owner notification requirements. The lack of medical assessment of the bite incident could further strengthen your position if it was used as justification for euthanasia.

Given the complexity of animal law cases and the emotional toll they take, consulting with an attorney who handles animal rights cases would be your best next step. They can review California's specific laws regarding shelter operations and animal control procedures to determine the viability of your case. While the passing of the only witness creates an evidentiary challenge, documentation (or lack thereof) from the shelter might provide sufficient basis for pursuing damages for the wrongful destruction of your pet.