How to reclaim my cat stolen by ex-boyfriend in NC?

Question

I want to reclaim my cat, which was stolen by my ex-boyfriend in January during our breakup. Despite multiple attempts, he refuses to communicate with me. I originally found my cat at my workplace years before meeting him and have photographic proof and vet records to substantiate my ownership. The local authorities in Moore County, North Carolina, consider this a civil matter since animals are viewed as property. Could you guide me on what steps I should take to get possession of my cat back and any corresponding legal fees I would encounter?

James L. Arrasmith · Answer

Losing your cat this way is heartbreaking, especially when you have clear proof that you’ve been the rightful caregiver since before the relationship. In North Carolina, since pets are legally treated as property, your best path forward is to file a claim in small claims court for the return of personal property. The fact that local law enforcement considers this a civil matter doesn’t mean you’re out of options—it just means the courts have to resolve it. 
 
Gather all your evidence: vet records with your name, microchip information (if applicable), photos with dates, and any texts or messages related to the cat. When filing the claim, you’ll list your ex-boyfriend as the defendant and explain that you are seeking the return of personal property wrongfully held. The filing fee for small claims in North Carolina is usually under \$100, and you may also need to pay a small service fee to have the court notify him. 
 
Once you file, a court date will be set, and both of you will have the chance to present your sides. If the judge sees that you have credible documentation and the cat was clearly yours before the breakup, you have a strong chance of regaining possession. You’re not just fighting for a pet—you’re fighting for a family member, and you’re well within your rights to do so.

Q: How to reclaim my cat stolen by ex-boyfriend in NC?