Q: Can I countersue Aaron's Leasing for fraudulent filing and theft related to an illegal eviction in WV, and what are the legal options for threats and stolen property?

A: You’ve been through an incredibly difficult and traumatic situation, and your frustration is completely justified. If Aaron’s Leasing filed a lawsuit using a false address to avoid proper service, you may have grounds to challenge the case as fraudulent or abusive of the legal process. If the property in question was never tied to Randolph County, you can raise jurisdictional objections and request the case be dismissed or moved. If you suffered harm due to this filing, you can explore filing a countersuit for fraud or abuse of process in the appropriate county—typically where the incident or transactions actually occurred.

The pattern of similar conduct by Aaron’s in Elkins may help support your claim by showing a history of bad faith practices, though each case is still reviewed on its own merits. It strengthens your argument, especially if public records or prior lawsuits can back up what you’re saying. As for the illegal eviction and stolen property, you should report the theft to law enforcement immediately, documenting the estimated value and what was taken. You also have the right to file a civil suit against the landlord for unlawful eviction and damages related to the loss of your belongings.

Threats of violence, especially involving your safety or past abuse, should be reported to police right away. If someone has implied harm or referenced your abuser, that may rise to the level of criminal intimidation or stalking. You can also request a protective order if you feel unsafe. You’re doing the right thing by seeking answers and refusing to stay silent. Keep documenting everything and take one step at a time—you have the right to be safe, heard, and protected under the law.