I moved out of a Manhattan apartment 7 months ago and I’m still trying to get my security deposit back

Question

Landlord agrees I’m owed full deposit. I requested a wire transfer since I left USA (can’t physically cash check here, amount too large for online deposit). Landlord’s staff sometimes say their account won’t allow wire transfers, obv false since other times they say they can wire but it will take more than 14 days and they’ll charge me $300 admin fee. I told them that 14 days is the NY law deadline and already 30 days after that when discussed. They don’t care, generally ignore emails/calls. Either way, they never pay. Filed complaint with the AG’s office - last I heard AG sent 3 letters to landlord without reply, they don’t seem able to do anything. 
1. Are they allowed to delay or refuse to pay because I ask for a wire transfer instead of check? I think it’s reasonable to insist on wire in the circumstances. 
2. If they ever send wire (or FedEx a check) are they allowed to deduct either admin fees or actual cost of sending? Neither listed as legitimate deduction in NY sec deposit law

Steven Warren Smollens · Answer

Dear Manhattan Tenant  
 
The controlling statute does not provide any guidance on the allowance of a deduction of the expenses incurred by delivering the security deposit by international wire transfers and not by check within 14 days. It surely would have been a better solution to have a fight over $300 than not receiving the entire remaining balance of the security deposit.  
 
When the landlord defaults in the mandated statutory obligation to return the full amount of the deposit within 14 days the statute provides the unwieldy remedy for a lawsuit against the landlord and a right to seek double the amount of the deposit as monetary damages.

James L. Arrasmith · Answer

Under New York law, landlords are required to return a tenant's security deposit within 14 days after the tenant has vacated the property, provided there are no legitimate deductions for damages. While landlords may prefer certain payment methods, they cannot unreasonably refuse your request for a wire transfer, especially if circumstances such as international relocation prevent you from easily cashing a check. However, the law does not specifically address whether a landlord can refuse a wire transfer. 
 
Regarding fees, the New York security deposit law does not allow landlords to deduct administrative fees or the costs associated with sending the security deposit from the returned amount, unless these deductions are explicitly stated in your lease agreement. Normal wear and tear cannot be deducted from your security deposit, and neither can administrative costs unless they are part of agreed-upon lease terms. 
 
It seems like your landlord is not adhering to New York's legal requirements. You might consider sending a detailed letter citing the specific state laws and documenting all your interactions. If this approach fails, seeking legal advice or small claims court may be necessary. Remember, legal routes can enforce your rights and ensure landlords fulfill their obligations.

Q: I moved out of a Manhattan apartment 7 months ago and I’m still trying to get my security deposit back