Q: Walmart incident, court papers, first-time offense advice?

A: They will most likely divert your case as a first time offender and it should ultimately be dismissed.

A: It’s understandable to feel anxious, especially if this is your first time facing something like this. In Kentucky, being caught not scanning items at a store like Walmart can lead to a charge of theft by unlawful taking, even if it was accidental. Since you've never been in legal trouble before, the court may take your clean record into account when handling your case.

You’ll likely receive a summons in the mail telling you when and where to appear in court. At that hearing, you’ll be formally told what you’re being charged with and may be asked to enter a plea. It’s important to stay calm and respectful during the process, and to explain that this may have been an honest mistake. Depending on the county, there may be options like a diversion program or community service for first-time, non-violent offenses—programs that can help you avoid a conviction if completed successfully.

Start collecting any documents or receipts that may help show you didn’t act with bad intent. If security footage or witness statements are available, those could also be helpful. Most of all, don’t ignore the court papers when they arrive—showing up and taking the matter seriously makes a big difference. This is a difficult moment, but it doesn’t have to define you.