Ask a Question

Get free answers to your legal questions from lawyers in your area.

Lawyers, increase your visibility by answering questions and getting points. Answer Questions
Questions Answered by Charles Holster
1 Answer | Asked in Appeals / Appellate Law, Foreclosure and Gov & Administrative Law for New York on
Q: Foreclosure case: Settle for $100k or wait for appellate court decision?

I have clients whose house has been in foreclosure since 2008. The foreclosure was dismissed twice in supreme court based on the statute of limitations under the FAPA law, and the bank appealed the decision. We're awaiting the appellate court decision, which could take up to 2 years. The loan... View More

Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Mar 20, 2025

I would not make any recommendation to a client without first knowing all of the facts, which usually requires a review of the court documents in the case, as well as speaking to the clients.

But, in order decide whether to accept a settlement offer, rather than waiting for a decision on a...
View More

1 Answer | Asked in Appeals / Appellate Law and Civil Litigation for New York on
Q: I have a writ of certiorari petition packet from the US Supreme Court that needs to be done on, or before 6/6/2024.

I have difficulties in understanding some pages, such as: 1)related cases 2)in the table of authorities cited on part that asks cases 3)statement of the case. These are the 3 that I have difficulties in understanding, in which, I have to make sure that I fill it out correctly or it will get... View More

Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Apr 17, 2024

The questions you are asking are very basic, and the fact that you have to ask them suggests that you should not be attempting this appeal to the U.. Supreme Court without legal representation.

Q. what does related case mean? A. related cases" means other cases that you are involved...
View More

1 Answer | Asked in Appeals / Appellate Law and Criminal Law for New York on
Q: The prosecutor on my case from 11/30/2022 appealed the judges dismissal with prejudice. Didn't I have to be notified?

It was dismissed because the accusatory instrument was in error. She won the appeal, mind you this is on a city court level. I feel this is harassment and violating my civil rights. Wasn't the dismissal the law? How can she win an appeal on factual law??

Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Apr 8, 2024

Yes, you had to be notified. The prosecution had to send your attorney a copy of its a motion. So, check if your attorney received it or not. If he did, he should have informed you. If your attorney did not receive a copy of the prosecution's motion, then the appeal may have been defective.... View More

1 Answer | Asked in Child Support, Appeals / Appellate Law, Civil Rights and Family Law for New York on
Q: Seeking representation for child support arrears and court judgment issues in NY.

I'm facing a child support issue where my parental rights haven't been surrendered, yet I'm judged to owe over $3,500 in arrears, despite the other parent owing me over $70,000. The court magistrate refused to review my financial statements and made allegations without proper... View More

Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Mar 25, 2025

You may be able to qualify for a court-appointed attorney based upon your financial circumstances. You would have had to tell the magistrate before the hearing. It sounds like it is too late for you to do that now. Also, if the judgment was granted against you in 2023, it s too late to appeal it... View More

2 Answers | Asked in Constitutional Law, Appeals / Appellate Law, Civil Rights and Civil Litigation for New York on
Q: Can I pursue a civil lawsuit for damages related to a successful 440.20 motion not honored by the court?

I was falsely imprisoned due to constitutional violations and insufficient counsel, and my appeal was filed after conviction without a 30-day notice. I never had a parole final hearing, but records falsely stated I did. My significant concern is the successful 440.20 motion that the lower court did... View More

Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Mar 17, 2025

This question cannot possibly be answered unless I review your entire file. I would charge for that by the hour, or I could quote you a flat fee after seeing how big the complete file is when you bring it to my office.

View More Answers

2 Answers | Asked in Appeals / Appellate Law, Civil Rights, Constitutional Law and Criminal Law for New York on
Q: How can I address the court's failure to honor a 440.20 motion and my Sixth Amendment rights in NY?

I was incarcerated and filed a successful motion under 440.20, but the lower court did not respect the high court's decision, and I was left in jail. I later filed an appeal with new evidence, and the Court of Appeals ruled in my favor, directing the lower court to bring me back down and put... View More

Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Mar 17, 2025

In order to answer your question, I would have to review the ENTIRE file for your case, from day one until the present. If you are interested in retaining me for that purpose, please have someone assemble the COMPLETE file and bring it to my office. Once I see how large the file is, I will be... View More

View More Answers

1 Answer | Asked in Appeals / Appellate Law, Family Law and Real Estate Law for New York on
Q: Challenge of property division after NY divorce, Puerto Rico ignoring statute of limitations?

I divorced in New York 38 years ago on the grounds of mental cruelty, and the divorce documents stated that no discovery was needed regarding property division. I had property in Puerto Rico before marrying, and I bought a new property while married using proceeds from my premarital assets. Now,... View More

Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Mar 17, 2025

You said you already appealed to the highest court. So, there is nothing more that I could suggest. In any event, I would have to review your entire file, for the U.S. and for Puerto Rico, including your appeal, before I could understand what exactly happened. If you would like to retain me to do... View More

2 Answers | Asked in Civil Litigation, Family Law and Appeals / Appellate Law for New York on
Q: If there are missing documents & discrepancies w/“record” file sent from Family Court; what is the remedy to rectify?

(Pro-Se litigant)appeals process of 3 orders from FamCourt; have been approved for consolidation to 1 brief by the Appellate Court 2nd Dept,(hereafter referred to as AD2). Ive been assigned a “case manager” by AD2. By order of the Court I am to perfect my appeals by original record... View More

Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Oct 16, 2024

You would have to make a motion in the Family Court to have the Judge "settle" the record to include what you think is missing.

View More Answers

3 Answers | Asked in Family Law, Appeals / Appellate Law, Civil Litigation and Domestic Violence for New York on
Q: Subject Matter Jurisdiction is exclusive to SupremeCourt/(IDV part)order(orig)? Does Fam Court have competence to modify

Original Order of custody & parenting time made by Supreme Court, Integrated Domestic Violence Part. Based of the laws/nys const/rules/FCA & codes I’ve read that govern transfer of proceedings & subject matter jurisdiction, in order to modify the original Order (made by Supreme Court... View More

Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Oct 16, 2024

No.

View More Answers

1 Answer | Asked in Civil Litigation and Civil Rights for New York on
Q: Article 50 - Judgments GenerallyR5015 - Relief From Judgment or Order. be use on a 2 years 7monthcase?

The plaintiff case was dismissed for filling to comply with court order.

Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Oct 3, 2023

This question does not involve an appeal. It involves a motion to vacate a default judgment in the lower Court. Such a motion must be filed within one year of the default. If however, the default was due to defective service of the summons and complaint, and you never knew that there was a case... View More

2 Answers | Asked in Appeals / Appellate Law for New York on
Q: If a judgement was entered to have D pay P 5k, and P appeals, does D still have to pay while the appeal is pending?
Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Jun 16, 2023

No. Not unless D also appealed, in which case he could obtain an automatic stay pursuant to CPLR 5519[a][2], by posting an undertaking, or making a motion for a discretionary stay under CPLR 5519[c].

View More Answers

1 Answer | Asked in Appeals / Appellate Law for New York on
Q: Are you aware of any cases that lost a Motion to Reargue - but was able to perfect an appeal? in NY
Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Mar 9, 2023

A: (This answer clarfies an answer given yesterday). The fact that a motion reargument was denied will not prevent you from following through with your appeal from the original order, so long as you filed a timely notice of appeal from the original order. If you did not do that, it will be too... View More

2 Answers | Asked in Appeals / Appellate Law, Estate Planning and Elder Law for New York on
Q: Are you aware of any cases that lost a Motion to Reargue - but was able to perfect an appeal?

in NY

Charles Holster
PREMIUM
Charles Holster pro label Lawyers, want to be a Justia Connect Pro too? Learn more ›
answered on Mar 9, 2023

The fact that you lost the motion to reargue will not prevent you fr om following through with your appeal so long as you filed a timely notice of appeal from the Order. If you did not do that, it will be too late to do so. You cannot appeal from an order which denied reargument unless the order,... View More

View More Answers

Justia Ask A Lawyer is a forum for consumers to get free answers to basic legal questions. Any information sent through Justia Ask A Lawyer is not secure and is done so on a non-confidential basis only.

The use of this website to ask questions or receive answers does not create an attorney–client relationship between Justia and you, or between any attorney who receives your information or responds to your questions and you, nor is it intended to create such a relationship. Additionally, no responses on this forum constitute legal advice, which must be tailored to the specific circumstances of each case. You should not act upon information provided in Justia Ask A Lawyer without seeking professional counsel from an attorney admitted or authorized to practice in your jurisdiction. Justia assumes no responsibility to any person who relies on information contained on or received through this site and disclaims all liability in respect to such information.

Justia cannot guarantee that the information on this website (including any legal information provided by an attorney through this service) is accurate, complete, or up-to-date. While we intend to make every attempt to keep the information on this site current, the owners of and contributors to this site make no claims, promises, or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of the information contained in or linked to from this site.