Kristina M. Bergsten's answer If he gave you the dog, then it’s yours. He would have to sue you and win to get the dog back. However, because there are clearly some details that you did not post here, it would be best if you met either an attorney to go over all the facts to get your best resolution.
Kristina M. Bergsten's answer You should probably speak with local, Georgia attorneys on this issue. Your pug sounds like he means business, so it's best to discuss it with an attorney from your jurisdiction.
Juliet Piccone's answer If a criminal case is filed, you could be entitled to restitution for the value of the dogs, but it's up to a judge and only if there is a conviction. Since you want to find your dogs, you should sue her civilly under a replevin theory. These are complicated cases, so while the courts do have forms you can fill out to file on your own, it really makes sense to hire an attorney that handles custody cases. There are other potential claims you can add that could even entitle you to attorney...
Juliet Piccone's answer That sound like it violates the requirements of Colorado's fake assistance animal law. Google it or perhaps seek a legal consult from someone like me that deals with this frequently.
Juliet Piccone's answer I'm not sure how the detective is going to cite or arrest her for theft if you and they do not know where she lives. You aren't going to get anywhere without knowing where she is located, because how will she be served with a criminal or a civil summons? In my opinion, you need a real consultation from an attorney who handles these cases all the time, like me, not just a random post on Justia. We could discuss what information is known, what is unknown, and how to fill in the gaps and...
Kristina M. Bergsten's answer It is unclear from your question what you are asking. Who is "she"? If you gave a dog to someone and they are returning the dog to you, it is up to you whether or not you take the dog back. If they gave the dog to a third person, they can do that because you relinquished ownership (based on your question) to the "some people."
Kristina M. Bergsten's answer Potentially. You will likely need to provide documentation from a medical professional detailing your disability/emotional disability and that your dog alleviates these symptoms.
Kristina M. Bergsten's answer He would have to sue you in small claims court and win to get her from you. Its possible he could call the police but they likely won’t get involved. You have a strong defense against his claims of Ownership, especially if the dog never lived with him and always lived with you.
Juliet Piccone's answer I'm sorry you are experiencing this, but it's not a simple issue. You need to talk to someone who handles these cases a lot, which I do. It pays to hire someone experienced, so please consider paying for a consultation with me. Free consultations are usually worth what you pay for them; nothing!
Kristina M. Bergsten's answer Wow! That is quite the situation you are in! Since person B is the original owner, most likely the cat belongs to him/her. But if persona A and B made an agreement that person A is the new owner, then it belongs to person A. More facts are needed to properly analyze this question. Either way, it sounds like these people need to come to an agreement or take it to court to let the court decide who owns the cat.
Kristina M. Bergsten's answer I’m confused by your last sentence whether you have your dog back, but if you do not you can call the police and ask them to help you get your dog back. You can press charges for theft, destruction of Propety (vandalism), and trespassing. The cops will likely ultimately decide what to charge this person with.
Kristina M. Bergsten's answer You need to sue her in replevin ASAP! If she works for a shelter, then there is only 5 days before the dog is considered "abandoned" and legal title of the animal transfers to the shelter. It sounds like you have been in contact with her, and she should meet you, but if she is not, it sounds like she needs some prodding from the legal system to get her attention.
Kristina M. Bergsten's answer It is possible animal control would confiscate your dog, pending a hearing on the criminal charges against you for the death of the other dog. I would recommend speaking to an animal attorney to go over your options and defenses and make sure your dog is not euthanized as a result of this case.
Mr. H. Michael Steinberg's answer My experience is the service dog is returned to the original owners much like a stolen car is returned to the rightful owners while the case is being prosecuted and after the theft is well documented for a possible trial at a later time.
Juliet Piccone's answer The answer is no. Typically the police will not intervene, they will say it's a civil matter. I've only seen a few cases where they have charged someone with theft of a dog. You will need to take them to court. I'd recommend you consult with an attorney who handles matters like this on a regular basis, such as myself.
Juliet Piccone's answer Pursuant to state law, the shelter has to hold dogs with ID for five days (three for dogs without ID). Once the hold period is up they can do whatever they want with the dogs, so make sure you've put in written requests to adopt both dogs NOW and follow up daily.
Mr. H. Michael Steinberg's answer No they cannot keep the property if it has been stolen even if it was purchased in good faith. They become another victim of the crime and are entitled to compensation called restitution. But unless the owner agrees to relinquish the dog in this case - it must be returned. H
Justia Ask a Lawyer is a forum for consumers to get answers to basic legal questions. Any information sent through Justia Ask a Lawyer is not secure and is done so on a non-confidential basis only.
The use of this website to ask questions or receive answers does not create an attorney–client relationship between you and Justia, or between you and any attorney who receives your information or responds to your questions, nor is it intended to create such a relationship. Additionally, no responses on this forum constitute legal advice, which must be tailored to the specific circumstances of each case. You should not act upon information provided in Justia Ask a Lawyer without seeking professional counsel from an attorney admitted or authorized to practice in your jurisdiction. Justia assumes no responsibility to any person who relies on information contained on or received through this site and disclaims all liability in respect to such information.
Justia cannot guarantee that the information on this website (including any legal information provided by an attorney through this service) is accurate, complete, or up-to-date. While we intend to make every attempt to keep the information on this site current, the owners of and contributors to this site make no claims, promises or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of the information contained in or linked to from this site.